Staying Calm Through The Recent Big Fall In Stocks

Yesterday night, the S&P 500 in the US swiftly fell by 7% when the market opened, triggering a circuit breaker that halted trading activity for 15 minutes. The index resumed trading, but eventually registered a drop of 7.6% for the day.

The decline in US stocks was sharp and it likely had hurt some investors, if not psychologically, then literally (because of fear-induced selling, or the activation of stop-losses). Some of you are also likely worried about what could happen next.

History is and will never be a perfect guide for the future. But a look at the past can give us context on what just happened and prevent us from committing emotion-driven mistakes.

19 October 1987 is known as Black Monday in the investing community. That’s because the S&P 500 fell by 20.5% on that day alone. What deepened the pain was that the US stock market index had already declined by 10.1% in the three days preceding Black Monday. So in the span of four trading days, from the close on 13 October 1987 to 19 October 1987, the S&P 500 sunk by a mighty 28.5% in total.

The chart above illustrates how brutal Black Monday was. But for another perspective, the chart below shows how the S&P 500 did from 13 October 1987 to 13 October 1992, a five-year period. It was up 30% in all. Not fantastic, but there was still a gain. 

Let’s zoom out even further, with a chart that shows the performance of the S&P 500 from 13 October 1987 to today:

Turns out, the S&P 500 has climbed by 773% in total, or a solid 6.9% per year.

I have two points to make here. First, significant short-term declines in stocks have happened before. When Black Monday occurred, it was likely an extremely stressful time for investors [link added on 11 March 2020]. But the sun still rose and the world went on. According to Robert Shiller’s data, the S&P 500’s earnings per share (EPS) has also compounded at 6.9% per year from October 1987 to today. In fact, the S&P 500’s EPS in December 1987 was higher than it was in October 1987 (US$16.41 vs US$17.50). And if the S&P 500’s dividends were included, the index’s return from October 1987 to today would have been around 10% per year, based on Shiller’s data.

The second point is that we need to separate business performance – especially long-term business performance – from stock price movements when investing. As I just mentioned, US businesses were growing (in the form of higher EPS) despite Black Monday’s occurrence, and continued to grow over the long run. Yesterday night’s 7.6% fall in the S&P 500 was driven by a slew of factors, with one of them being fears related to the new coronavirus, COVID-19. I described some of the virus’s negative impacts on business conditions worldwide in a recent article:

“Global corporate giants such as Apple, Visa, and Mastercard have warned of pressures to their businesses because of COVID-19 (see here, here, and here). Airlines are some of the worst-hit groups of companies, with UK airline Flybe entering bankruptcy earlier this month; last week, Southwest Airlines in the US warned of a “very noticeable, precipitous decline in bookings.” In China, the PMI (purchasing managers’ index) for February 2020 came in at 35.7, the lowest seen since tracking began in 2004 (a reading below 50 indicates a contraction in factory activity). In 2008 and 2009, during the height of the Great Financial Crisis, China’s PMI reached a low of 38.8. ”

So yes, there’s a very real threat to the short-term health of many businesses because of COVID-19. But will the virus have any lasting negative consequences over the long run? It’s possible, but I think it’s unlikely. I’m not alone. During an interview with CNBC late last month, billionaire investor Warren Buffett shared his thoughts on how investors ought to be dealing with COVID-19. He said (emphasis is mine):

“Look, the tariff situation was a big question market for all kinds of companies. And still is to some degree. But that was front and center for a while. Now coronavirus is front and center. Something else will be front and center six months from now and a year from now and two years from now. Real question is — where are these businesses gonna be five and ten and 20 years from now? Some of them will do sensationally, some of them will disappear. And overall I think America will do very well — you know, it has since 1776…

…We’ve got a big investment in airline businesses and I just heard even more flights are canceled and all that. But flights are canceled for weather. It so happens in this case they’re gonna be canceled for longer because of coronavirus. But if you own airlines for 10 or 20 years you’re gonna have some ups and down in current. And some of them will be weather related and they can be all kinds of things. The real question is you know, how many passengers are they gonna be carrying 10 years from now and 15 years from now and what will margins be and– what will the competitive position be? But I still look at the figures all the time — I’ll admit that…

…[Coronavirus] makes no difference in our investments. There’s always gonna be some news, good or bad, every day. In fact, if you go back and read all the papers for the last 50 years, probably most of the headlines tend to be bad. But if you look at what happens to the economy, most of the things that happen are extremely good. I mean, it’s incredible what will happen over time. So if somebody came and told me that the global growth rate was gonna be down 1% instead of 1/10th of a percent, I’d still buy stocks if I liked the price at which — and I like the prices better today than I liked them last Friday…

… We’re buying businesses to own for 20 or 30 years. We buy them in whole, we buy them in part. They’re called stocks when we buy in part. And we think the 20- and 30-year outlook is not changed by coronavirus.”

But not every company is facing the same level of long-term risk because of COVID-19. Some companies are at higher risk of failing or having their health permanently impaired. These are companies with debt-laden balance sheets, lumpy revenues, and an inability to generate healthy free cash flows. Such companies have always faced a higher level of existential risk compared to companies with healthy balance sheets (that have minimal or reasonable levels of debt), recurring revenues, and strong free cash flows. But COVID-19 has raised even more questions on the survivability of the former group because of the intense short-term hit to business conditions worldwide.

We always need to tread carefully with the types of companies we invest in – more so today. But there’s no need to panic. Fear could be the biggest contributor to our investing-losses, even more than actual risks.

Disclaimer: The Good Investors is the personal investing blog of two simple guys who are passionate about educating Singaporeans about stock market investing. By using this Site, you specifically agree that none of the information provided constitutes financial, investment, or other professional advice. It is only intended to provide education. Speak with a professional before making important decisions about your money, your professional life, or even your personal life.